Homeowners comparing clay vs concrete roof tiles often find that the two look alike from the street. Both bring the classic Mediterranean style that suits so many Florida homes. Both handle sun and heat well. But they differ in weight, durability, color and cost.
Clay tile is made from natural clay that’s shaped and fired in a kiln. Its color comes from the clay itself, so it holds its color for decades. Clay tile is very durable and can last a very long time when the underlayment beneath it is kept in good shape. It’s also lighter than concrete in many cases. On the downside, clay is more brittle. It can crack if walked on carelessly, and it usually costs more for both material and labor.
Concrete tile is made from sand, cement and water, molded into shape. It’s the most common tile on Tampa Bay homes. Concrete tile is strong, comes in many profiles and colors, and generally costs less than clay. It’s heavier, though, and the color is often applied as a surface coating that can fade over time. Concrete tile can also absorb more water, which can lead to stains or algae.
In both cases, the tile isn’t the only barrier. The underlayment under the tile does most of the work keeping water out. Over time, Florida heat breaks it down, even if the tiles look fine.
Weight is a key part of clay vs concrete roof tiles for older homes. Switching from shingles to tile, or from one tile to a heavier one, may require an engineering check of the roof structure.
Whatever the choice between clay vs concrete roof tiles, Florida’s building code sets strict rules for how tile is attached in high-wind zones. A qualified roofer will follow them.
Coastal Brothers Roofing, a family-owned roofer serving Pinellas, Pasco, Hillsborough and Hernando counties, installs and replaces tile roofs. Call (727) 931-7663 for a free inspection.
